ArcaMax

Reader Question: I live in a residential neighborhood, and my next-door neighbor operates a business out of his pole barn. Township zoning bans commercial activity here. The town shut him down once, but he's back at it. Will having a business next door lower my property value?

Monty's Answer: Your concern about property values is legitimate, but the impact depends on several factors that aren't always straightforward. The good news is that value loss is neither inevitable nor permanent. Your leverage is the ordinance if you use it methodically.

It is unclear how well you know your neighbor or how long you have been neighbors. Was the pole barn there when you moved in? If the two of you get along, consider having a meeting. Whether it be noise, traffic or odors, you can share your concerns. Before the meeting, check with zoning to see if he qualifies for a conditional use permit. It is unclear if the operation bothers you or if your concern is only that it may affect the value should you decide to sell.

Evaluate the Circumstances

No. 1: The type of business matters significantly. A quiet home office or small craft operation might have minimal impact, while a noisy auto repair shop or heavy manufacturing could substantially affect your property's appeal and value.

No. 2: In strong real estate markets, buyers might overlook minor commercial intrusions, especially if they believe the issue will be resolved. Market conditions, school districts, overall neighborhood trends and economic factors often outweigh the impact of a single problematic neighbor.

No. 3: Consider insulating your curb appeal. Plant fast-growing evergreens or install an opaque fence along the shared lot line. Upgrade windows on the affected facade to dual-pane or add interior sound panels. Motion-sensing exterior lights can neutralize late-night activity.

No. 4: Neighborhood zoning violations worry purchasers and lenders alike. They also fear traffic, safety and aesthetics. You preserve your peace and the neighborhood's residential character by acting now.

No. 5: Documentation becomes crucial if you ever need to prove damages. Keep records of zoning violations, township enforcement actions, noise complaints, traffic issues or any other problems the business creates. Photograph or video evidence of commercial activity can support your case if you later pursue legal remedies.

No. 6: Consider escalating the enforcement issue. Since your township has already shut down the operation once, that action has established a precedent for enforcement. Email the zoning administrator for three documents: the zoning code section that prohibits the use, the written notice of violation already issued and any follow-up or compliance deadlines. The statute and prior warning turn your complaint from a "neighbor dispute" into an "enforcement file."

No. 7: You might also explore legal options. Some jurisdictions allow affected neighbors to seek injunctions or damages for zoning violations. An attorney specializing in municipal or real estate law can advise whether you have grounds for action and what remedies might be available.

No. 8: Your property's marketability could suffer more than its actual value. Upon discovering the zoning violation, some buyers will immediately cross your home off their list, reducing your pool of potential purchasers. Fewer buyers could extend your selling timeline and potentially force price concessions.

Your best strategy combines persistent enforcement advocacy with careful documentation while recognizing that many situations eventually resolve themselves through natural attrition or regulatory pressure.

Richard Montgomery is a nationally syndicated columnist, published author, retired real estate executive, serial entrepreneur, and the founder of DearMonty.com. He provides consumers with free options to pressing real estate issues. Find him on Twitter(X) @dearmonty or DearMonty.com.

----

Copyright 2025 Creators Syndicate, Inc.