Maryland has no consistent way to ensure abusers surrender guns, report says
Published in News & Features
BALTIMORE — Three-quarters of domestic homicides in Maryland involve a firearm, yet the state has no consistent system for ensuring that people ordered to surrender their guns in intimate partner violence cases actually comply, according to a new report.
“When you insert a firearm into an already volatile situation, we know that our clients, the survivors around us, are at much greater risk,” said Amanda Rodriguez, chief executive of TurnAround, a Baltimore-area nonprofit that has served survivors of sexual assault and domestic violence for nearly five decades. “And the numbers solidify that.”
The Battered Women’s Justice Project and its primary partner, Community Legal Services, wrote the 60-page report called “Safeguarding Survivors: Examining Domestic Violence Protective Order Firearm Removal Practices to Improve Safety Outcomes.”
The BWJP and Community Legal Services studied the domestic violence firearm surrender process for each of Maryland’s 23 counties and Baltimore City.
During discussions with people involved in Maryland’s domestic violence protection system, researchers found that the process for requiring abusers to surrender firearms largely operates on the “honor system.”
“There are no clear deadlines for surrendering firearms, no consistent verification mechanisms, and no reliable court-based compliance monitoring,” the report found. “Participants expressed frustration that if a respondent simply claims they have no firearms or that they already transferred them to another person, law enforcement has limited recourse.”
“The law is the same [throughout the state], but how you implement that law is largely jurisdiction-specific,” said Megan Belden, a senior advisor for BWJP.
The lack of a clear and consistent process for firearms surrender puts survivors of domestic violence at greater risk, said Monica N. Player, director, legal protections, with BWJP.
“What we found in the state of Maryland is that the onus is on the respondent to turn in their firearm after the issuance of a protection order that prohibits them from possession of that firearm,” Player said. “The way the process works, once the final protection order is issued, prohibiting the respondent from having possession of that firearm, they are mandated to turn it in, but there’s no deadline, and there’s no structure or format for how they turn it in. That’s why it’s referred to [by someone who took part in a listening session] as the ‘honor system.’ ”
Overall, 671 firearm fatalities occurred in Maryland in 2024, of which 55% were homicides, the report found. In 2022-23, 75% of domestic-related homicides were committed with a firearm. Data for 2025 has not yet been released.
The report is part of Maryland’s broader effort to address gun violence, following a 2024 law that established the Center for Firearm Violence Prevention and Intervention within the Maryland Department of Health. The center is seeking nonprofit organizations to examine how the state handles firearm surrender under domestic violence protective orders and recommend ways to improve the process.
Maryland lawmakers seek tougher gun surrender rules
Rodriguez is working with state lawmakers on legislation to ensure domestic violence survivors receive contact information for comprehensive support organizations. State lawmakers are also working on legislation that would tighten the process for the removal of firearms when a domestic violence survivor obtains a temporary protective order, Rodriguez said.
State Sen. Shelly L. Hettleman, a Democrat who represents Baltimore County, said she plans to introduce legislation to fill the gaps the report found in the firearm surrender process. The legislation will address “many of the points in this report about how fragmented our system is in addressing firearms and civil protection orders,” Hettleman said. “Specifically, in keeping survivors safe from abusers who have firearms.”
The service of a protective order is an “extremely volatile” period for domestic violence survivors, Rodriguez said. “We know that the time for lethality is highest around those protective orders,” Rodriguez said.
A recent Baltimore Sun analysis found that thousands of protective orders, also known as peace orders, were dismissed because law enforcement failed to serve the orders. About half of the roughly 243,000 petitions filed across Maryland eventually failed, according to the analysis. Challenges in serving the orders accounted for about 8% of those dismissals.
Report details weaknesses in firearm surrender process
Among the study’s key findings:
—Recovery is most effective when temporary protective orders are served in person, but enforcement, compliance checks and follow-up often falter at the final protective order stage, when surrender is mandatory.
—Courts, law enforcement and advocacy groups rely heavily on paper-based information sharing. Courts often receive no confirmation that firearms have been surrendered, leaving judges unable to monitor compliance.
—Domestic violence survivors often must request firearm surrender, verify that it happened and report violations themselves. Cultural concerns, immigration fears and threats of retaliation create additional obstacles, particularly for marginalized communities.
The report recommends several steps for Maryland policymakers and communities:
—Establish a statewide process for assessing firearm access, ordering surrender, setting deadlines, notifying respondents of their obligations in multiple languages and involving survivor advocates.
—Replace the informal honor system with documented proof of surrender, clear deadlines and consequences — including warrants or contempt proceedings — for noncompliance.
—Replace paper-based processes with electronic data sharing between courts and law enforcement, and expand the Maryland Gun Center’s role in tracking compliance in real time.
The report advances the discussion about how to improve safety for domestic violence survivors, Rodriguez said.
“Shining a light on this issue can lead to our policymakers making changes that can ensure survivors get the information so they can keep themselves safe,” Rodriguez said.
©2026 Baltimore Sun. Visit baltimoresun.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments