Jury weighs fate of South Florida pastor at center of Haiti presidential killing
Published in News & Features
MIAMI — Federal prosecutors and lawyers for a South Florida pastor accused of conspiring to overthrow Haiti’s president and install himself as the country’s leader agree on this: President Jovenel Moïse was shot to death in his bedroom on July 7, 2021, and his wife, Martine, was severely wounded.
They also agree that the bloody crime was carried out in the dead of night by Colombian mercenaries, 17 of whom have yet to go to trial after being transferred from a Haitian jail to South Florida to face federal conspiracy charges.
But whether Christian Emmanuel Sanon, a Boynton Beach resident who for years portrayed himself as a doctor and pastor, played a role in the assassination plot — and should face a possible life sentence — is where the two sides diverge.
On Tuesday, as Sanon’s eight-week trial in a Miami federal courtroom drew to a close, prosecutors and defense lawyers again offered starkly different portraits of the man at the center of the sprawling conspiracy.
Defense lawyers characterized Sanon, 68, as a “good person” with the “heart of a pastor” who wanted better for Haiti. But he was deceived, they argued, by men posing as federal agents, one of who was actually working as a confidential informant for the FBI.
“A lot of people were unhappy,” defense lawyer Zeljka Bozanic said, referring to the political crisis that dogged Moïse as he faced questions about when his presidential mandate ended and critics accused him of trying to become Latin America’s next dictator while he ruled by decree.
“Mr. Sanon wanted to fix that. He’s been meeting with the leaders since 2020,” she said during her two-hour closing. “He started talking to people, people knew he was interested in politics.”
Prosecutors, meanwhile, portrayed him as a greedy and desperate con artist whose craving for wealth, power and respect drove him to orchestrate a violent overthrow of Haiti’s government, culminating in Moïse’s assassination.
“Sanon knew about the final plan to kill Moïse at his house. He knew that the Colombians were staging at a new location, preparing for the operation,” Assistant U.S. Attorney Jason Wu told jurors about the days leading up to July 7.
Wu argued that despite Sanon’s claims he had been cut from the plot, he continued living with the Colombians and communicating with other members of the conspiracy. He also arranged food, and “intentionally joined with them to commit the crime,” Wu said.
During his closing, Wu drew on Sanon’s own testimony during his three days on the witness stand. He also highlighted testimony from five “insiders” turned government cooperators who pleaded to conspiring to kidnap or kill Moïse and providing material support to the effort.
Wu pulled out an automatic rifle, which he described to jurors as the murder weapon, and displayed a photograph of the slain president. It was taken at 1:58 a.m. on July 7, 2021, and showed Moïse’s bloodied body lying on the floor of his disheveled bedroom, one eye protruding out of its socket.
Sanon, prosecutors said, remained deeply entrenched in the conspiracy even after plotters shifted their support to a fired judge from Haiti’s Superior Court, Windelle Coq Thélot.
“He could have turned around and walked away,” lead prosecutor Sean McLaughlin said during the government’s rebuttal. Sanon didn’t run, he said, because he was hoping to get a job with the new administration.
“He’s sitting ... waiting for things to turn his way, deleting all the messages in his phone just like his wife told him,” McLaughlin said.
Failed coup, facing financial ruin
According to prosecutors, the plot began unfolding in February 2021 when Sanon saw a failed coup in Haiti as an opportunity to try and seize power.
“After years of masquerading as a legitimate doctor, a businessman, a philanthropist, this is where the defendant found himself at the start of 2021,” Wu said, showing a copy of Sanon’s bank statement. “With $195 in the bank.”
Sanon also was deeply in debt, owing tens of thousands of dollars to his longtime friend, Frederick Bergmann, a Tampa businessman who testified against him after reaching a plea deal with the government.
Sanon’s plan, prosecutors said, was to “plunder the nation of Haiti.” To achieve this, he promised lucrative infrastructure government contracts in exchange for his supporters helping him “create a coup to kidnap and kill Moïse.”
The most serious charges facing Sanon are conspiring to kill or kidnap a person outside the United States, namely Moïse, and conspiring to provide material support to cause his death. Sanon is also charged with providing that material support, resulting in the president’s death. Each of those three counts carries up to life in prison.
In addition, Sanon is charged with two counts of conspiring to commit an offense against the United States, which carries a maximum of five years for each count; participating in a military expedition against Haiti, a friendly nation of the United States, which has a maximum of three years imprisonment; smuggling ballistic vests from the U.S. to Haiti, which has a maximum of 10 years; and submitting false or misleading information on export forms. That count carries a maximum of five years.
After closing arguments, Sanon’s fate was handed over to a jury.
Before adjourning for the day, the 12 jury members received instructions on how to determine whether Sanon was guilty of the eight charges in the sprawling indictment, in which dozens of additional defendants were added just days before his case began in September.
During the closing, Wu displayed photographs of more than 50 people on courtroom monitors, including four men convicted earlier this year in connection with the plot.
Wu and McLaughlin urged jurors to convict Sanon on all counts, arguing that he recruited financial backers and his own private army, namely the nearly two dozen Colombian former soldiers — and even tried recruiting gang members and disgruntled former police officers to help him seize power.
“Again, so much happened right within South Florida in the U.S.,” said Wu, who highlighted an April 7, 2021, meeting at Fort Lauderdale’s Tower Club and a meeting in Doral at the offices of the security firm, Counter Terrorist Unit Security and Counter Terrorist Federal Academy.
Other meetings took place in Weston and Miramar, at convicted financier Walter Veintemilla’s house and offices.
Bozanic, Sanon’s defense lawyer, urged jurors to acquit him on all counts, arguing that prosecutors had wrongly portrayed him as the mastermind of the conspiracy.
She focused much of her argument on Arcangel Pretel Ortiz, a former Colombian intelligence operative convicted in May who was also an active FBI informant while the plot unfolded.
“The two-timing confidential informant,” Bozanic said, describing him also as someone “who lies to everybody, including his handlers.”
She reminded jurors of an exchange in which Pretel had asked Sanon to call an FBI agent before departing for Haiti on a chartered plane. Sanon, she said, had left his phone number for the agent.
“Does a man who wants to kidnap the president or kill the president or do anything illegal say to the FBI agent, ‘Hey, this is my number here in the U.S.?’” Bozanic asked.
Bozanic also challenged the government’s efforts to tie Sanon to other alleged conspirators, questioning their credibility and motives. She pointed to Joseph Vincent, who she said walked around with a fake State Department pin “because he wants to be somebody.”
She also disputed prosecutors’ description of James Solages as Sanon’s “hit man,” “underling” and someone he regarded as a son. Solages and Vincent, both Haitian Americans, had accompanied the Colombian former soldiers.
Solages, Bozanic said, was cozying up to Pretel, as shown by text exchanges introduced into evidence. She displayed a graphic of messages between the men in which they discussed keeping their deals with Coq Thélot “a secret” from Sanon.
While prosecutors argued that phone records with some of the conspirators show Sanon’s continued involvement with the plot, Bozanic and her co-counselor Humberto Dominguez again challenged the interpretation of the records.
“When the men are hungry, he is going to give them ... food,” Bozanic said, arguing that the government is prosecuting him because they are equating the act as material support.
The defense also pointed to a June 28 audio recording in which German Rivera, one of the leaders of the Colombian squad, outlined the attack to a group of former soldiers without identifying the president as the intended target. Solages was at the meeting, but not Sanon.
“They lie to them, and at the same time, what they do is they sing a happy birthday song to James Solages’ child,” she said, criticizing prosecutors for not presenting the recording.
It was disturbing, she said, because in the same breath while singing happy birthday, the men are talking about “killing babies and killing everything that moves”
“Those are the type of people that took stand,” Bozanic said in one of several instances where she questioned the credibility of the government’s witnesses.
“What happens in June is this group separates from Sanon,” the lawyer stressed. “They separate from Sanon because Sanon no longer fits their description. Because Sanon wants to go meet political leaders, he wants to go meet the church members. He wants to talk to people and do demonstrations.”
©2026 Miami Herald. Visit at miamiherald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments